Technical purchasing
Melt Flow Index for Recycled PS and HIPS: How to Compare a TDS and COA
Understand MFI, MFR and MVR for recycled PS and HIPS. Compare TDS and COA data, align test conditions and plan an application-based material approval.

Illustrative finished-part inspection scene; not a Cherein batch test record.
Introduction
Melt flow index is useful when buying recycled PS or HIPS, but the number is meaningful only with its units, test temperature, load and method. Use it to screen and monitor material, then validate the grade on the intended production process. A higher MFI is not automatically better, and matching MFI values do not prove that two materials will perform identically.
This becomes important when a buyer receives several quotations with attractive but incomplete specifications. One sheet might show a single typical value. Another might show a range. A third might give an actual result for a named production lot. Treating all three as the same type of evidence can lead to a poor purchasing decision.
The purpose of this guide is to connect the laboratory number to a practical buying workflow. It explains the difference between MFI, MFR and MVR; distinguishes a technical data sheet from a certificate of analysis; and shows how to define a material acceptance process without inventing universal limits.
The examples below are teaching examples, not Cherein batch records, laboratory results or guaranteed product specifications.
What Does Melt Flow Index Measure?
MFI is a commonly used term for a melt-flow measurement. When the reported result is a mass-flow rate, it is usually expressed in grams per ten minutes, written as g/10 min. The measurement describes flow under a specified laboratory condition rather than every condition encountered inside an extruder or injection-moulding machine.
ISO 1133-1:2022 describes methods for measuring melt mass-flow rate and melt volume-flow rate under stated temperature and load conditions. Its public abstract also notes that the relatively low shear rates of these measurements can limit their correlation with normal processing behaviour. Source: ISO 1133-1:2022.
That makes MFI useful as part of an incoming-material control system. It does not make it a complete description of melt behaviour, product quality or machine compatibility.
MFR and MVR are different quantities
MFR is a mass-flow rate, while MVR is a volume-flow rate, typically expressed in cm³/10 min. If one data sheet reports mass and another reports volume, the numbers should not be compared as though the units were interchangeable.
ISO explains that conversion between these quantities requires the melt density at the test temperature. Room-temperature pellet bulk density is not a substitute for that information. Source: ISO 1133-1:2022.
When asking for a clarification, quote the complete line from the document. “Please confirm whether this is MFR in g/10 min or MVR in cm³/10 min, and provide the measurement condition” is more effective than “Please confirm the MFI.”

Why the Test Condition Matters
A reported value is incomplete without its measurement context. At minimum, establish the test method, temperature, load and units. For a purchase specification, also clarify the procedure and the relevant sample preparation or conditioning instructions.
Consider an illustrative comparison: Supplier A reports “MFI 8,” while Supplier B reports “MFR 12 g/10 min.” Neither description alone establishes which grade is more suitable. The buyer still needs the measurement conditions and the relationship between those results and the intended application.
Do not apply an informal conversion factor between different loads or temperatures. If the conditions differ, request a result under the agreed condition or ask the testing laboratory to explain an appropriate comparison method.
ISO and ASTM should be identified precisely
ASTM D1238 also covers melt-flow testing using an extrusion plastometer. Its official description identifies quality-control uses and warns against treating flow-rate uniformity as proof of uniformity in unrelated properties. ASTM also notes that its standard and ISO 1133 differ in technical content. Source: ASTM D1238-26.
Specify the agreed standard and edition in the purchase documents. The currently listed edition is not necessarily the edition used for an older data sheet or an existing customer approval. If a method changes, assess the effect before combining old and new results in one trend chart.
TDS vs COA: Which Document Answers Which Question?
A technical data sheet usually describes a product grade and its reported characteristics. A certificate of analysis normally records selected results associated with an identified lot. Neither document should be assumed to contain a contractual guarantee unless the supplier’s statements and the purchase agreement establish that meaning.
| Document or record | What it helps establish | What still needs checking |
|---|---|---|
| TDS | Grade identity and technical reference information | Whether values are typical, specified or guaranteed |
| COA | Reported results for an identified lot | Sample identity, methods, limits and connection to the shipment |
| Approved specification | The agreed purchasing requirements | Revision, acceptance process and responsibilities |
| Production trial report | Performance under recorded operating conditions | Whether those conditions represent the intended application |
| Retained sample record | A physical reference linked to a lot or trial | Storage, identification and authorised comparison method |
A “typical” value is not automatically a maximum, a minimum or an allowed tolerance. Ask for the meaning of each important number before writing it into an incoming-inspection checklist.
What a usable COA should identify
Request the product grade, lot number, relevant date, reported property, result, units and method. Where a pass/fail decision is required, establish the agreed limits and the person or organisation responsible for releasing the lot.
Check that the lot reference also appears on the bags or shipment records. A technically detailed document is less useful if the receiving team cannot connect it to the material in the warehouse.
Does Higher MFI Mean Better Recycled Material?
No. The preferred flow behaviour depends on the part and process. The objective is a material that runs within an acceptable operating window and produces conforming parts at a practical cost.
For injection moulding, a buyer may investigate flow in relation to filling a particular geometry. For extrusion, the discussion may include output stability and the behaviour of the complete formulation. Neither task can be reduced to selecting the largest number in a supplier comparison table.
Match a known operating window
Start with the current approved material and record what the process does with it. Establish normal settings, output or cycle behaviour, part weight, dimensions and the relevant quality checks. Then evaluate candidate material against that reference.
If a replacement requires major adjustments, investigate whether the resulting process remains acceptable. A technically possible run is not necessarily a stable commercial process. Record the adjustments instead of describing the replacement as a direct equivalent without qualification.
Avoid diagnosing the material from flow alone
A changed MFI can justify investigation, but it does not by itself establish the cause. Feedstock composition, processing history, formulation and measurement differences may all need attention. Confirm the sample and test condition before drawing conclusions about degradation or contamination.
Likewise, a matching result does not eliminate other concerns. Colour, foreign material, odour, moisture-related handling issues or finished-part performance can still differ. Treat MFI as one signal within the approval system.

How to Compare Two Supplier Data Sheets
Use the following sequence before discussing a price premium or approving a substitute.
Step 1: Confirm that the product categories match
Identify whether the proposal concerns recycled PS, recycled HIPS or an expandable bead grade. Record the intended production route and any formulation information the supplier can substantiate. A trade name or recycled-content claim alone does not establish equivalence.
For terminology, see Cherein’s product range. For process-specific questions, use the existing HIPS injection-moulding selection guide.
Step 2: Complete the measurement description
Copy the flow result, units, temperature, load, method and edition into a comparison sheet. Mark missing information as “unconfirmed.” Do not fill an empty cell with a convention from another supplier’s document.
Step 3: Classify the evidence
Label each result as a typical grade reference, a declared specification or a lot-specific result. If that distinction is unclear, ask the supplier. Compare like evidence with like evidence before discussing whether a difference is significant.
Step 4: Link the number to a trial
Arrange a sample linked to the proposed grade and lot. Decide what the factory testing will measure and who will approve the finished product. Keep the specification, sample record and trial report together.
Need help reviewing a material specification?
Send Cherein your current TDS, the MFI test condition, the intended application and the difficulty you are trying to solve. Our team can discuss available product information and the requirements for a useful sample evaluation. Send Your Requirements.
How Should Buyers Set a Batch Acceptance Range?
Build the range around application evidence, measurement capability and the agreed supply specification. Do not copy a narrow tolerance from an unrelated grade or accept a broad range simply because it appears on a marketing page.
A practical sequence is to characterise an approved material, evaluate representative candidate lots and establish which variation the production process can tolerate. Where the programme justifies it, involve both the material supplier and the buyer’s testing team in that work.
Separate specification limits from operating observations
An agreed purchasing limit defines a commercial acceptance requirement. An observation from a single trial describes that trial. One successful result does not establish the full allowable range.
For example, a material that ran acceptably on one machine at one recorded result has not necessarily been validated at every value surrounding it. Keep that uncertainty visible while additional evidence is collected.
Define the response to an out-of-range result
Agree how the material will be held, how the sample identity will be confirmed and whether repeat or referee testing is appropriate. The written procedure should identify who can release the lot and how disagreement will be resolved.
Do not quietly blend a disputed lot into approved stock to make a number appear acceptable. Mixing changes the material being evaluated and can destroy useful traceability. Any proposed rework or blend should be reviewed and documented before use.
What If the Buyer and Supplier Obtain Different Results?
Begin with traceability and measurement alignment. Confirm that both laboratories tested material from the same identified lot and that sampling did not introduce a different composition or contamination.
Compare the method, edition, procedure, conditioning, temperature, load, instrument records and result calculation. Ask the laboratories to review repeatability and reproducibility using the applicable standard and their own quality procedures. The existence of two different numbers does not establish which laboratory is wrong.
If the difference affects release, retain sufficient material and use the agreed dispute procedure. An independently arranged test can help, provided the sample chain, method and interpretation are defined in advance.
Keep communication factual: lot identification, reported results, test conditions, production observations and the decision required. “The material feels different” can start an investigation, but it cannot replace the records needed to resolve it.

A Worked Example of a Document Review
Imagine a buyer receives a TDS showing a typical flow value of 8 g/10 min and a proposed shipment COA showing 9 g/10 min. These are hypothetical figures. The difference alone does not establish acceptance or rejection: the typical reference may not be a limit, and the two measurements may use different conditions.
The buyer first confirms the product identity, then checks that temperature, load and method match. Next, the buyer locates the agreed purchasing specification. If that document does not define an acceptance range, the correct action is to resolve the missing requirement rather than invent a tolerance after seeing the result.
If the lot meets an agreed specification but the production trial shows unacceptable performance, document both facts. The laboratory screen may be satisfactory while the application remains unsuitable. Conversely, a short successful trial does not authorise ignoring an agreed out-of-range result. The release decision should follow the written agreement and the customer’s approval process.
This example shows why technical, commercial and production records need to remain connected without being treated as interchangeable evidence.
Which Checks Should Accompany MFI?
Choose additional checks according to the finished product and the known risks. Avoid requesting a long list of unrelated numbers that nobody will use in a release decision.
For a visible industrial casing, relevant questions may include colour consistency, moulded appearance, dimensions, fit and the required mechanical performance. For a decorative profile, investigate cut quality, surface finish, dimensional stability and installation preparation. For other applications, different checks may take priority.
Where moisture, ash or another laboratory indicator is used, identify its method and purpose. A lower value is not automatically a complete measure of “purity,” nor does it demonstrate every aspect of product performance.
During shipment inspection, connect documents to bags, packaging condition and lot labels. After arrival, preserve that connection through warehouse storage, feeding and production records. An excellent laboratory result cannot compensate for lost lot identity.
FAQ
What is the difference between MFI and MFR?
MFI is a widely used trade term. MFR identifies melt mass-flow rate, commonly reported in g/10 min. Confirm the actual reported quantity and method rather than relying on the abbreviation, especially when comparing documents from different suppliers.
Can two recycled HIPS grades with the same MFI be substituted directly?
Not on that evidence alone. Compare the complete specification and validate the proposed grade against the actual part, machine and customer requirements. Flow matching does not establish matching colour, mechanical behaviour, cleanliness or service performance.
Can I compare results measured at different temperatures or loads?
Do not compare the numbers as direct equivalents. Request testing under a common agreed condition or obtain a technically justified comparison from the testing organisation. An informal arithmetic correction can create a misleading approval decision.
Does a TDS replace a COA?
No. A TDS describes the grade’s technical reference information; a COA provides reported information tied to an identified lot. Establish which properties and limits are contractual, and verify that the shipment can be traced to the relevant lot record.
What MFI should I request for recycled PS extrusion?
There is no universal answer. Start with the current formulation, equipment, profile and approved operating window. Request a candidate grade with a stated test condition, then evaluate the formulation on the intended production line.
Should every MFI difference lead to rejection?
Use the agreed specification and release procedure. First verify sample identity and measurement comparability. A difference within an agreed acceptable range may not require rejection, while an out-of-range result should trigger the defined hold and review process.
Conclusion
MFI becomes a useful purchasing tool when it is connected to a complete measurement description, an identified material lot and an application-specific approval process. Read the TDS, COA and purchase specification as different pieces of evidence. Then connect that evidence to factory testing and finished-part requirements.
Request Product Data for Your Application
Share your current grade, process, target properties and monthly demand with Cherein. We can discuss the current TDS and available batch information for the proposed product, together with the next steps for evaluation. Request Product Information or contact sales1@cherein.com.
